Whale Watching in Madeira: Catamaran vs RIB, Funchal vs Calheta

I Did Both the Catamaran and the RIB Boat, Here's

I’d heard every horror story about whale watching in Madeira, friends who’d spent three hours heaving over the rail, kids crying, the whole “I saw more sea than whale” experience. So when I boarded the catamaran in Funchal for a March trip, I took seasickness tablets, sat in the back, and braced for misery. The Atlantic was like glass. We saw a pod of spotted dolphins within 15 minutes, then a sperm whale surfacing 200m off the starboard side, the guide said it was a juvenile, about 8 meters long. Nobody got sick. Not one person. The marine biologist onboard said the early season (March to May) has the calmest sea conditions because the trade winds haven’t picked up yet. Now that’s the only window I recommend for nervous first-timers.

But that was just one trip. Over the course of a month, I did four whale watching tours, two on catamarans from Funchal, two on RIBs (rigid inflatable boats) from Calheta. I wanted to know which one actually delivers the top whale watching Madeira tour experience. The answer depends entirely on what you care about: comfort, wildlife proximity, photography, or seasickness risk.

Madeira Dolphin & Whale Watching Tour, The Catamaran Experience

We earn a commission when you book through our links on Viator (PID P00303273), at no extra cost to you.

I booked the Madeira Dolphin & Whale Watching Tour from Funchal marina on a bright Tuesday morning. The catamaran holds about 40 people, but the group was closer to 25, enough space to move around without elbowing for railing space. The marine biologist on board gave a quick briefing: sperm whales and pilot whales are resident year-round, blue whales pass through March to May, and dolphins show up on roughly 95% of trips. Whales on 30-40%. The boat left at 9 AM, and within 20 minutes we were motoring past the Cabo Girão sea cliffs, heading southwest toward deeper water.

The catamaran is stable. I mean stable. I watched a woman in her 70s walk to the front deck without holding the handrail. The crew served water and tea. There’s a shaded cabin and a sun deck. If you’re prone to motion sickness, this is your boat. The downside: you’re higher above the water, so when a sperm whale surfaces, you see its back and spout clearly, but you don’t get that eye-level connection you’d get from a smaller boat. For families with young kids or anyone who wants a relaxed morning on the water, this is the right choice.

Why the Catamaran Nearly Won Me Over

After the first catamaran trip, I almost cancelled my RIB bookings. The catamaran was comfortable, the crew was knowledgeable, and we saw wildlife. But I kept thinking about something the biologist said: “The whales don’t care what boat you’re on. But the RIB can get closer because it’s quieter and more maneuverable.” That stuck with me. I wanted to see what the other side looked like.

There’s also the logistics factor. Funchal marina is central, easy to reach from most hotels, with plenty of parking garages nearby. The tour operator has a kiosk right on the waterfront. You show up 15 minutes early, they hand you a life jacket, and you’re off. No fuss. If you’re staying in Funchal or Caniço, the catamaran is the obvious choice. But if you’re based on the west coast, Ponta do Sol, Calheta, Porto Moniz, driving to Funchal at 7:30 AM adds an hour you could be sleeping. That’s where the Calheta departure starts to make sensory.

Whale & Dolphin Watching Calheta, The RIB Boat Experience

I drove from Ponta do Sol to Calheta marina in 15 minutes. The Whale & Dolphin Watching Calheta tour uses a 12-person RIB, basically a rigid hull with inflatable tubes, like a military zodiac but with seats. The guide handed out waterproof jackets and told us to keep our phones in dry bags. “You will get wet,” he said. He wasn’t exaggerating.

The RIB skims across the water at 25 knots. You feel every wave. The first 15 minutes were exhilarating, wind in my face, spray hitting the sides, and then we slowed near a pod of pilot whales about 5km offshore. The difference was immediate. From the RIB, the whales were at eye level. I watched a mother and calf surface 15 meters from the boat. The calf rolled on its side and looked at us. I could see individual barnacles on its skin. The guide cut the engine and we drifted in silence for five minutes while the pod passed underneath. No other boats within sight.

The trade-off: I was wet, cold, and a little nauseous on the ride back. The RIB has no cabin, no toilet, no tea station. If the sea is choppy, and it often is in the afternoon, you’ll be bouncing. This tour is not for anyone with back problems, pregnancy, or a weak stomach. But for photographers and adventure seekers, it’s the clear winner. The lower angle gives you shots you can’t get from a catamaran, and the smaller group means you’re not competing for views.

The Moment I Made My Decision

I went back to the catamaran one more time, partly for research, partly because my friend from Lisbon was visiting and wanted the “safe” option. We left Funchal at 9 AM, saw a pod of common dolphins riding the bow wave for 20 minutes, and then spotted a sperm whale logging on the surface about 300m away. The biologist said it was resting, they do that between dives. We stayed at a respectful distance for 15 minutes, then the whale lifted its tail and dove. Everyone on board clapped. It was a good trip.

But I kept comparing it to the RIB experience. On the catamaran, the whale was a distant shape, impressive, but distant. On the RIB, I felt like I was with the animals. The difference between watching a nature documentary on a 55-inch screen versus standing in the same room as the animal. If your priority is comfort and you just want to see whales, take the catamaran. If you want to connect with them, and you can handle a bumpy ride, take the RIB.

For most people visiting Madeira, I’d recommend this: if you’re staying in Funchal or east of the city, book the catamaran tour for your first trip. It’s reliable, comfortable, and you’ll almost certainly see dolphins. If you’re staying in Calheta, Ponta do Sol, or anywhere on the sunny southwest coast, save yourself the drive and book the RIB tour from Calheta. The proximity to the animals is worth the splash.

What I Wish I'd Known Before I Went

1. Morning trips are calmer, book the 9 AM slot. The trade winds pick up around noon, turning the Atlantic into a washing machine. Every tour operator runs morning and afternoon departures. Choose morning. Your stomach will thank you.

2. Take seasickness tablets 30 minutes before departure. Even on the catamaran. I didn’t on my second trip and spent 20 minutes feeling green while a family of five happily watched dolphins. The crew had ginger candies, but by then it was too late. Buy the tablets at any pharmacy in Funchal, they cost about €4.

3. The whales don’t care about your schedule. On my third trip (RIB, afternoon), we saw exactly zero whales. Dolphins, yes, a big pod of 30+, but no whales. The guide said that’s normal: whales are wild animals, not performers. The 30-40% whale sighting rate is real. If you absolutely must see a whale, go in March-May when blue whales pass through and sperm whales are more active. Or book two tours to increase your odds.

4. Calheta is warmer than Funchal. The southwest coast gets more sun and less wind. On the same day, Funchal was 22°C with a breeze, while Calheta was 27°C with almost no wind. If you’re prone to seasickness, the calmer conditions at Calheta might actually make the RIB more tolerable than you’d expect.

5. Bring a dry bag for your phone and camera. The catamaran is dry. The RIB is not. Saltwater spray will kill your phone. I learned this the hard way when my iPhone stopped responding to touch after the second RIB trip. A €10 dry bag from Decathlon in Funchal (near the hiking poles aisle) is cheap insurance,.

6. Check the IPMA marine forecast before booking. The Portuguese weather service (IPMA maritime forecast) gives wave height and wind for Madeira’s south coast. If the forecast says waves over 1.5m, skip the RIB and go catamaran. If it’s under 1m, either option works. I check this the night before every trip.

7. The top whale watching Madeira tour for you depends on your base. If you’re reading this while planning your trip, look at where you’re staying. Funchal? Catamaran. West coast? Calheta RIB. Don’t drive 45 minutes each way just to save €10 on a tour, the fuel and parking will cost more than the difference.